A curated index of software evaluated for how it treats user authority, records, and ongoing capabilities. This is an unscored qualitative catalog, not a ranking.
A call for verification and independent evidence
Software sovereignty cannot be proven by marketing promises, documentation claims, or open-source licenses alone. Under our evaluation framework, fundamental requirements (such as independent clean-machine recovery and governability of destructive operations) require direct, reproducible laboratory verification.
Because of this rigorous standard, most candidates currently hold an overall determination of Insufficient evidence. We actively invite researchers, engineers, and digital preservation practitioners to help test these applications:
- Execute laboratory recovery tests: Run clean-machine restoration trials (T2, E3) and cross-tool format migrations (T1, E2) in isolated environments.
- Audit operational boundaries: Verify undo, rollback, and authorization controls for destructive operations and sync conflicts (T4, E5).
- Submit independent reviews: Contribute parallel assessments following the Two-Assessor Protocol.
To contribute verification records, test fixtures, or new application entries, see our contribution guidelines in the repository.
Local-first zero-based budgeting. Runs entirely offline against a local SQLite database and synchronizes across devices via verifiable Hybrid Logical Clock CRDT messages.
- Data format
- Client-Side SQLite + Merkle CRDTs
- Recovery model
- Self-Hosted Docker Sync with E2EE
- Limitations
- Automatic backups clear CRDT message/clock history; native-file import replaces sync context. An archive is not a demonstrated complete sync-server backup.
Full evaluation
Spaced-repetition flashcard application with a local collection and package export.
- Data format
- Local SQLite collection, exported as .apkg packages
- Recovery model
- Local collection with optional sync service
- Limitations
- Newer collection formats are compressed, so direct SQLite inspection depends on the version. No target application was installed or executed in rating reconciliation batch 2; source controls are not end-to-end recovery observations. The legacy fixture contains one note/card and a four-byte media member, not a representative modern collection.
Full evaluation
Digital audio workstation that keeps sessions as folders with an XML session file.
- Data format
- Session folder with an XML file (.ardour) and audio files
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application
- Limitations
- Session XML refers to separate media; readable references do not prove a complete archive. A missing-plugin placeholder can retain state without reproducing the plugin's sound. The retained session is historical; it does not establish current-release round-trip compatibility.
Full evaluation
Audio editor with version-dependent SQLite-backed project formats and standard audio exports.
- Data format
- SQLite-backed AUP3/AUP4 projects with encoded structure and audio blocks
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application
- Limitations
- SQLite can expose tables without decoding project structure or recovering audio. The retained AUP4 sample failed sample-block reads and integrity_check in the generic reader; this is not a proven application-wide failure. Legacy AUP3 and inspected AUP4 evidence must not be treated as interchangeable.
Full evaluation
Plain-text double-entry accounting that checks ledger invariants locally, without bank scraping or a subscription.
- Data format
- UTF-8 plain-text Beancount ledgers
- Recovery model
- Git version control or file sync
- Limitations
- Readable postings with omitted amounts/costs still require accounting interpretation. Automatic padding can add balancing entries; balance success alone does not prove historical completeness.
Full evaluation
macOS bibliography manager that uses BibTeX files as its native format.
- Data format
- BibTeX plain-text files (.bib)
- Recovery model
- Local files; macOS only
- Limitations
- A readable group representation does not establish retention by other bibliography managers. Linked-file encodings reference separate documents and can include platform-specific bookmark/alias data.
Full evaluation
3D creation suite with a built-in Python interface and a binary project format.
- Data format
- Binary .blend files, with Python scripting and open export formats
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application
- Limitations
- Published SDNA layout does not by itself recover geometry, dependencies or editable scene meaning. Pack All has explicit exclusions and is not a complete dependency inventory.
Full evaluation
Command-line backup program with deduplication and optional encryption, writing to repositories the user controls.
- Data format
- Deduplicating archive repository with optional encryption
- Recovery model
- Local or SSH repository chosen by the user
- Limitations
- Recovery depends on repository integrity, encryption keys and compatible software. Findings describe a pinned development tree, not verified behaviour of Borg 1.x or a released Borg 2 binary. Normal compaction closes the inspected soft-delete recovery window; Borg-specific TAR metadata needs an aware reader. No target application was installed or executed in rating reconciliation batch 2; source controls are not end-to-end recovery observations. Complete essential-record recovery and whole-scope consequential-operation coverage remain unverified.
Full evaluation
Peer-to-peer messaging application that stores messages on the participants' own devices and does not rely on a central server.
- Data format
- Encrypted local database on each device
- Recovery model
- Direct peer-to-peer over Tor, Wi-Fi, or Bluetooth
- Limitations
- Static primary-source review only; no Briar account created or deleted. A timer-control implementation is not proof of secure erasure or recoverability.
Full evaluation
Python library for scripted parametric CAD whose models are ordinary code.
- Data format
- Python scripts that export STEP and STL
- Recovery model
- Local Python environment; plain-text scripts suit version control
- Limitations
- STEP metadata is inspectable, but geometry and parametric constraints were not reconstructed. CQGI executes Python with real builtins.
Full evaluation
E-book library manager that keeps books in an ordinary folder tree with a metadata database and converts between many formats.
- Data format
- Folder library with metadata.db (SQLite) and per-book OPF metadata
- Recovery model
- Local library; sync left to external tools
- Limitations
- Complete recovery needs more than readable metadata.db; book files, covers and other library state still need comparison. Preference recovery depends on a usable separate backup; OPF-only reconstruction is a different recovery path.
Full evaluation
Non-destructive raw photography workflow that leaves original files unchanged and stores edits in XMP sidecar files and a library database.
- Data format
- Immutable RAW + ISO Standard .xmp Sidecars
- Recovery model
- Local Disk Hierarchy
- Limitations
- XMP parameters contain versioned module-specific binary data. Decoding their bytes does not reproduce the image or preserve every database-only library field.
Full evaluation
The grand-ancestor of sovereign personal computing. Unifies structured prose, deterministic agendas, tables, and literate programming inside immortal plain text.
- Data format
- Plain-Text .org Outlines
- Recovery model
- Git / rsync / Syncthing
- Limitations
- Readable Org syntax does not recover evaluated formulas, attachments or arbitrary Babel results. Babel controls are configurable; source defaults do not establish a user's effective security settings.
Full evaluation
Self-hostable software forge that provides Git hosting, issues, and pull requests on infrastructure the user controls.
- Data format
- Bare Git repositories plus a relational database
- Recovery model
- Self-hosted server
- Limitations
- Dump inclusion is not proof of a consistent live backup or complete restoration. The dump-repo non-empty-directory guard does not cover repository purge or other destructive commands.
Full evaluation
Engineered by the creator of SQLite. Packages version control, tickets, bug tracking, and wiki documentation into one durable SQLite file that runs an instant local web UI that works offline.
- Data format
- Single Standalone SQLite Database File
- Recovery model
- Peer-to-peer HTTP/SSH sync
- Limitations
- Pinned source inspection, not application execution. Full repository restoration, private/shunned artifacts, account/settings coverage and real purge recovery remain untested.
Full evaluation
Parametric 3D CAD modeller with a Python interface, with project files that are zip archives.
- Data format
- Project archive (.FCStd, a zip containing Document.xml and shapes)
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application; version control via external tools
- Limitations
- Project interpretation depends on the application version and workbench.
Full evaluation
Scientific Computing & GISLibrary and command-line tools for reading, converting, and inspecting raster and vector geospatial data.
- Data format
- Open geospatial formats through a translation library
- Recovery model
- Local command-line tools
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Driver-specific lossy conversion, geometry fidelity, actual overwrite behavior, sidecar-removal comparison and cross-version compatibility remain untested.
Full evaluation
Raster image editor with a native layered format and export to many open formats.
- Data format
- Native .xcf layered image, plus open export formats
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application
- Limitations
- The decoded fixture is legacy XCF version 0; modern file/pixel reconstruction remains open. ORA stores raster layer contents and has a mode fallback, so native editability and appearance need separate comparison.
Full evaluation
Distributed version control with user-held history, inspectable changes and local repository recovery; the assessed configuration and external dependencies are stated below.
- Data format
- Content-Addressable Merkle DAG (.git)
- Recovery model
- Decentralized SSH / HTTPS push-pull
- Limitations
- Passes apply only to the predeclared installed local-core configuration, not every Git deployment. A full bundle alone omits local configuration and submodule payloads; preserve these separately. Untracked clean deletion has no Git-history undo; external backup was required in the test.
Full evaluation
Self-hostable Git service that provides repositories, issues, and pull requests on infrastructure the user controls.
- Data format
- Bare Git repositories plus a relational database
- Recovery model
- Self-hosted server
- Limitations
- Dump skip flags and disabled stores can omit required data; a coordinated database/filesystem restore remains unverified. Repository YAML is inspectable, but complete account, permission and collaboration migration to another forge is unverified.
Full evaluation
System and package manager configured declaratively from plain-text files, with rollback and a separate channel and substitute model.
- Data format
- Declarative Scheme configuration files
- Recovery model
- Guix store with pinned channels; configuration kept in version control
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Channel-pinned rebuilds, network-blocked closure completeness, mutable-data restoration, generation deletion and release-specific compatibility remain untested.
Full evaluation
Scientific Computing & GISScriptable numerical computing environment with a language largely compatible with MATLAB.
- Data format
- Plain-text .m scripts and MAT data files
- Recovery model
- Local installation
- Limitations
- The inspected .mat examples contain Octave text, not binary MAT. Plain ASCII output omits imaginary parts and skips arrays above two dimensions.
Full evaluation
Scientific Computing & GISStatistical analysis program that reads and writes SPSS data files and uses a text syntax.
- Data format
- SPSS .sav data files and plain-text syntax files
- Recovery model
- Local installation
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Native SAV/POR compression compatibility, independent-reader comparisons, dictionary round trips, transformation reversibility and crash recovery remain untested. Savannah source-file retrieval failed; dated retained official manual pages are used instead.
Full evaluation
Double-entry accounting program with local data files and an SQL storage option.
- Data format
- Compressed XML data file, or SQLite or other SQL back end
- Recovery model
- Local file; the chosen storage backend determines its properties
- Limitations
- The exact-arithmetic checks cover two sample transactions, not a complete financial audit. Split value, quantity and commodity context cannot be treated as interchangeable fields.
Full evaluation
Scientific Computing & GISGeospatial analysis system with a scriptable command set and its own on-disk database layout.
- Data format
- Project, mapset, and raster/vector directories on disk
- Recovery model
- Local desktop and command line
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Pack/unpack equivalence, external database dependencies, raster/null/category fidelity, older-version opening and interrupted-write recovery remain untested.
Full evaluation
Plain-text double-entry accounting with a command-line and web interface, reading journal files the user keeps.
- Data format
- UTF-8 plain-text hledger journals
- Recovery model
- Git version control or file sync
- Limitations
- The journal example was read, not evaluated by hledger or another accounting engine. Import checkpoint state and input rules must be preserved to assess duplicate handling.
Full evaluation
Static site generator that compiles a whole site from plain files in milliseconds, offline. This site is built with it.
- Data format
- Plain-Text Markdown (.md) + TOML/YAML front matter
- Recovery model
- Single zero-dependency native binary
- Limitations
- Only disposable fixtures used with the explicitly recorded installed runtime. The cause of the installed/newer cleanup difference, a network-blocked production build, module/theme closure and deployment dry-run remain open.
Full evaluation
Vector graphics editor whose native format is SVG.
- Data format
- SVG (XML) with editor-specific metadata
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application
- Limitations
- The inspected SVG samples identify Inkscape 0.92-era creators, not a current release. Readable SVG paths do not guarantee preservation of editor-specific layers or live-effect controls. Export action registration was inspected; Plain SVG output was not generated.
Full evaluation
Reference manager built directly on BibTeX and BibLaTeX files.
- Data format
- BibTeX and BibLaTeX plain-text files (.bib)
- Recovery model
- Local files; versioning and sync left to external tools
- Limitations
- Group definitions use JabRef metadata comments. File fields store escaped links and optional source URLs, not the linked file bytes.
Full evaluation
Distributed communication application that does not require a central account server.
- Data format
- Local encrypted account archive and message history
- Recovery model
- Distributed peer-to-peer with account archive export
- Limitations
- Pinned daemon source only; client confirmation and actual device linking were not executed. AccountArchive JSON serialization is not a generic decrypted-archive reader test.
Full evaluation
Media server that streams a library of ordinary files the user already holds, without a mandatory account at a vendor.
- Data format
- Media files in folders, with a local server database and optional NFO metadata
- Recovery model
- Self-hosted server
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Same-version/cross-host recovery, complete archive coverage, media-byte preservation, per-user comparison, delete-media scope and observed network behavior remain untested.
Full evaluation
Offline-first note-taking application whose notes are Markdown, with several synchronisation targets and export options.
- Data format
- Markdown notes and attachments in a local SQLite database
- Recovery model
- Local-first with optional sync (Joplin Cloud, WebDAV, Nextcloud, Dropbox, OneDrive, or a file system)
- Limitations
- Native import generates new item IDs and rewrites links; export clears sharing fields. Revision history, keys, settings, and cross-version restore still require verification. No target application was installed or executed in rating reconciliation batch 2; source controls are not end-to-end recovery observations. Complete essential-record recovery and whole-scope consequential-operation coverage remain unverified.
Full evaluation
Next-generation version control where even conflicts and rebases are recorded as deterministic, first-class mathematical states in an undoable local operation log.
- Data format
- Append-only Operation Log + Git Backend
- Recovery model
- Git-compatible remotes / Native local
- Limitations
- Pinned source inspection, not application execution. Conflicted-change export, actual operation-store copying, older-version recovery and abandon/garbage-collection behavior remain untested.
Full evaluation
Video editor that stores projects as XML on top of the MLT framework.
- Data format
- XML project files (.kdenlive) referencing source media
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application
- Limitations
- The inspected XML references external media. Readable timelines and implemented path rewriting do not establish asset completeness or render equivalence.
Full evaluation
Open-source password manager with a documented, encrypted vault file on your disk.
- Data format
- Open KDBX vault (binary, documented format)
- Recovery model
- Git / Syncthing (no commercial cloud)
- Limitations
- CSV omits attachment payloads, history, arbitrary custom attributes, and Auto-Type associations. The inspected KDBX 4+ plaintext XML extraction path omits attachment payloads; older XML can embed them.
Full evaluation
Electronic schematic capture and PCB design suite where every net, footprint, and trace is stored in human-readable S-expressions with zero cloud licensing.
- Data format
- Plain-Text S-Expressions (.kicad_sch/.kicad_pcb)
- Recovery model
- Git / Local Vendor Libraries
- Limitations
- Explicit PCB net references do not establish electrical or manufacturing correctness. External model variables require separately preserved assets/configuration. Archive selection can omit extras and hidden history; complete dependency recovery remains unverified.
Full evaluation
Media centre application that plays a local library and keeps its library state in local databases.
- Data format
- Media files in folders, with SQLite library databases
- Recovery model
- Local application; optional network sources
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Watched/resume/artwork round-trip comparison, independent database reading, profile migration/downgrade and observed cleanup/source-removal behavior remain untested.
Full evaluation
Offline-first learning platform that serves educational content from a local server.
- Data format
- SQLite database and content channels in a home directory
- Recovery model
- Local server for offline networks; optional sync between devices
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Actual backup restoration/content coverage, cross-device migration, user/log export completeness, downgrade behavior and runtime deletion/traffic observations remain untested.
Full evaluation
Backup tool with encrypted, deduplicated snapshots and a choice of storage back ends.
- Data format
- Encrypted content-addressed repository
- Recovery model
- Local, network, or cloud storage chosen by the user
- Limitations
- Repository recovery still requires the password and compatible tooling. The inspected ZIP writer skips symlinks and directory entries; TAR retains more structure but sets no ACL/xattr fields. Default snapshot verification does not read every file's full contents. No target application was installed or executed in rating reconciliation batch 2; source controls are not end-to-end recovery observations. Complete essential-record recovery and whole-scope consequential-operation coverage remain unverified.
Full evaluation
Document reader for e-readers and other devices that opens open e-book and document formats.
- Data format
- Reads open formats; reading state in per-book sidecar files
- Recovery model
- Local device files with optional sync plugins
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Actual cross-device/hash-mode migration, annotation-field comparisons across export formats, PDF checksum changes, release compatibility and backup restoration remain untested.
Full evaluation
Digital painting application with a documented project archive format.
- Data format
- Project archive (.kra, a zip containing maindoc.xml and layer data)
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application
- Limitations
- Archive/XML inspection establishes structure, not reconstruction of layer pixels or color appearance. OpenRaster uses projections for several layer types and is not established as a lossless editable-native backup.
Full evaluation
Full desktop office suite running 100% offline. Native files are standard zip containers holding documented XML (`content.xml`) extractable with basic POSIX unzip.
- Data format
- ISO/IEC 26300 OpenDocument XML (.odt/.ods)
- Recovery model
- Local Filesystem
- Limitations
- Independent ODT annotation parsing is not complete office-document rendering or formula/macro recovery. Backup replacement and transactional recovery paths are distinct; effective settings and failure outcomes remain unverified.
Full evaluation
Open-source outliner with distinct file-based and database graph models; preservation and exit depend on the graph type and export selected.
- Data format
- Version-dependent Markdown/Org file graphs or SQLite-backed database graphs
- Recovery model
- Graph-model-dependent local storage and synchronization
- Limitations
- Identity/timestamp/ontology preservation depends on the selected exporter and options. SQLite backup error cleanup is not proof of complete asset-inclusive recovery.
Full evaluation
Personal finance application that keeps its data in a local database file.
- Data format
- SQLite database file (.mmb), with an encrypted option
- Recovery model
- Local file; sync left to external tools
- Limitations
- Creating a schema is not recovery of a populated MMEX database. Rekeying can change compatibility; the inspected prompt is not an executed decryption/recovery test.
Full evaluation
Learning management system that an institution can host itself, with course backup files.
- Data format
- Relational database plus course backup archives (.mbz)
- Recovery model
- Self-hosted server; course backups restore to another instance
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Real course/site restore comparisons, student submissions/grade coverage, deleting-target recovery, plugin dependencies and version-specific migrations remain untested.
Full evaluation
Media player that plays local files directly and is configured through plain-text files.
- Data format
- Plays the user's own media files; configuration in plain text
- Recovery model
- Local command-line and desktop player
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Actual playback/cross-machine restore, version-option migration, scripts/subprocess/network observation and output/cache overwrite behavior remain untested.
Full evaluation
Music notation editor with a documented project archive and export to MusicXML.
- Data format
- Project archive (.mscz, a zip of XML), plus MusicXML export
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application
- Limitations
- The inspected score fixture was created by MuseScore 2.0.2, not the current application version. Backup creation is conditional and limited by the save path; crash-safe recovery was not demonstrated. Independent XML reading does not establish equivalent engraving or playback.
Full evaluation
Analog and mixed-signal circuit simulator that runs from human-readable netlists without network dependencies. Results depend on device models, solver settings, and version, so comparisons need stated tolerances.
- Data format
- Plain-Text SPICE Netlists (.cir / .sp)
- Recovery model
- Standalone POSIX CLI
- Limitations
- Pinned source inspection, not application execution. Independent decoding of real outputs, wrdata unit/scale comparison, external model closure and version-specific numerical behavior remain untested.
Full evaluation
Linux distribution configured declaratively from plain-text files, with rollback to earlier system generations.
- Data format
- Declarative Nix configuration files
- Recovery model
- Nix store with pinned inputs; configuration kept in version control
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Pinned-closure rebuilds, offline cache completeness, mutable service/secret restoration and actual rollback/GC trials remain open.
Full evaluation
Notes stay as standard UTF-8 Markdown files in a local folder you can edit in Vim, VS Code or bash.
- Data format
- Local Directory of Plain Markdown (.md)
- Recovery model
- Decoupled (Syncthing, Git, or paid first-party sync)
- Limitations
- Canvas file references require the separately preserved files and paths. The official Canvas specification does not establish behavior of Obsidian's closed-source application or plugins.
Full evaluation
Small, auditable operating system whose configuration lives in plain-text files.
- Data format
- Plain-text configuration files in /etc
- Recovery model
- Local filesystem / Git
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. An actual dump/restore chain, keydisk recovery, upgrade reversal and filesystem/metadata comparison remain untested.
Full evaluation
Code-first 3D solid modelling from plain-text scripts. Output can differ between versions and geometry engines, so reproducing a result needs stated versions.
- Data format
- Programmatic CSG Plain-Text Scripts (.scad)
- Recovery model
- Git Version Control
- Limitations
- A 3MF mesh/package does not preserve the original SCAD construction program. The inspected STL has no semantic source-parameter/unit fields and no populated triangle attributes. A normalized regression expectation is not itself a portable 3MF package.
Full evaluation
Document archive that stores original documents, archival derivatives and metadata, with a documented exporter.
- Data format
- Original documents, archival derivatives and a relational database
- Recovery model
- Self-Hosted Container / Local Filesystem
- Limitations
- Version mismatches warn and continue in the inspected importer; compatibility is not established. The optional passphrase protects specified credential fields, not the document files or entire export. Complete restore, OCR/relationship fidelity and destructive-workflow authorization remain unverified.
Full evaluation
Secrets live as individual GPG-encrypted files in a directory you control, with no third-party vault server.
- Data format
- GPG-encrypted files in a plain directory
- Recovery model
- Git / Syncthing (no commercial cloud)
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Actual private-key/trust recovery, prior-history decryption after recipient changes, importer completeness and observed offline behavior remain untested.
Full evaluation
Container engine that runs OCI containers without a central daemon and moves images as archives.
- Data format
- OCI images and containers
- Recovery model
- Local installation; images move through registries or archive files
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Named-volume/bind-mount/secret coverage, cross-runtime digest comparisons, ownership restoration, rootless migration and real prune trials remain open.
Full evaluation
Scientific Computing & GISGeographic information system that works with many open spatial formats and keeps projects as files.
- Data format
- Project files (.qgz, a zip of XML) over open geodata such as GeoPackage
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application; data held by the user or a server of their choice
- Limitations
- The inspected QGZ contains project XML and empty auxiliary storage, while its three layer datasets are external. It is not a self-contained data backup.
Full evaluation
Note-taking application that stores notes as plain Markdown files in a folder, with optional Nextcloud integration.
- Data format
- Markdown files in a user-chosen folder
- Recovery model
- Local folder with optional Nextcloud or ownCloud sync
- Limitations
- Tag/trash associations have database state that is not demonstrated recoverable from note text alone. Confirmation code is present, but effective settings and recoverability remain untested.
Full evaluation
Scientific Computing & GISLanguage and environment for statistical computing, with scripts and data in plain text or documented serialisation formats.
- Data format
- R scripts, CSV, and RDS serialised objects
- Recovery model
- Local installation with package repositories
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Factor/date/attribute/NA round trips, a non-R reader, older-release trials, package-library upgrades and workspace overwrite recovery remain untested.
Full evaluation
Digital audio workstation that works without a cloud account and stores projects in a text-based format.
- Data format
- Human-Readable ASCII Project Files (.RPP)
- Recovery model
- Portable local install (~15MB), proprietary licence
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Actual RPP/plugin-state inspection, backup/autosave defaults, clean-host consolidation, stem equivalence, version compatibility and evaluation-license behavior remain untested; the proprietary core was not inspected.
Full evaluation
Command-line backup program that stores encrypted, deduplicated snapshots in a repository the user controls.
- Data format
- Encrypted content-addressed repository
- Recovery model
- Local or remote repository chosen by the user
- Limitations
- Repository recovery requires preserved credentials and compatible tooling. Default check is not a full data read; subset checks do not cover every pack. ZIP omits ownership/ACL/xattr fields; TAR metadata restoration depends on a compatible receiver and filesystem. No target application was installed or executed in rating reconciliation batch 2; source controls are not end-to-end recovery observations. Complete essential-record recovery and whole-scope consequential-operation coverage remain unverified.
Full evaluation
Video editor that stores projects as MLT XML files.
- Data format
- MLT XML project files (.mlt) referencing source media
- Recovery model
- Local desktop application
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. A complex timeline reopened/rendered independently, filter/proxy closure, actual crash recovery, older-version opening and media consolidation remain untested.
Full evaluation
Embedded SQL engine with user-held database files and logical backup/restore interfaces; preservation depends on the schema, engine features and backup procedure.
- Data format
- Single Cross-Platform B-Tree Disk File
- Recovery model
- Local Embedded Engine (Zero Network)
- Limitations
- Ratings apply to the declared SQLite 3.45.3 API profile, not arbitrary clients or application databases. Explicit transactions and trace were configured; committed deletion has no automatic undo. WAL-aware backup is necessary; a live main-file-only copy can omit committed data.
Full evaluation
Peer-to-peer folder synchronisation with cryptographic device identities and conflict file preservation. It is synchronisation, not backup.
- Data format
- Direct Peer-to-Peer Block Exchange (BEP)
- Recovery model
- End-to-End TLS over LAN / Relay
- Limitations
- Source/retained-input inspection only; no installation or application restore performed. Two-peer deletion/conflict propagation, manual metadata recovery, config/database migration, destructive override/revert behavior and network observations remain untested.
Full evaluation
Command-line task manager with local task storage, JSON interchange and optional task synchronization.
- Data format
- Local task database with open JSON export
- Recovery model
- Local database with optional TaskChampion synchronization
- Limitations
- Filtered JSON export is not a full profile or synchronization backup. Import can modify tasks sharing a UUID; this batch did not execute those modifications. The inspected input literals do not establish complete recurrence, annotation or dependency recovery.
Full evaluation
The simplest possible task format: one line per task, with priority, project and context markers readable by any text tool.
- Data format
- Single plain-text file, one task per line
- Recovery model
- Git / Syncthing
- Limitations
- Plain-text portability does not standardize every extension's behavior. Completion/archive change source files and can remove priority; full recovery remains untested.
Full evaluation
Deterministic document typesetting from plain text that recompiles multi-page documents in milliseconds, offline.
- Data format
- Plain-Text Markup (.typ)
- Recovery model
- Single zero-dependency native binary
- Limitations
- Pinned source inspection, not application execution. An offline compile, explicit font inventory, cross-version output comparison and web-app export completeness remain untested.
Full evaluation
Desktop wiki that keeps each page as a plain text file in an ordinary folder.
- Data format
- Plain-text wiki-markup files in a notebook folder
- Recovery model
- Local folder; synchronisation is left to external tools
- Limitations
- The XML test container demonstrates readable structure, not a restored native notebook. Expected Markdown uses checkbox glyphs; another editor may not retain executable task-list semantics. Permanent deletion and system trash are distinct paths; actual recovery remains unverified.
Full evaluation
Reference manager that keeps a local library of bibliographic records and attached files, with export to standard citation formats.
- Data format
- Local SQLite database plus a storage folder of attachments
- Recovery model
- Local library with optional sync service; export to CSL JSON, BibTeX, and RIS
- Limitations
- A library export is not equivalent to a complete backup, and relationships may not survive reimport. No target application was installed or executed in rating reconciliation batch 2; source controls are not end-to-end recovery observations. The independently loaded schema contains no research records; storage and document-citation mappings were not recovered.
Full evaluation